Bad Kids: Race and the Transformation of the Juvenile Court by Barry C. Feld

By Barry C. Feld

In the previous 3 a long time, social and criminal adjustments have reworked the juvenile court docket from a nominally rehabilitative welfare organisation right into a second-class legal courtroom for younger offenders. contemporary efforts to "toughen" juvenile justice rules have led to more and more harsh sanctions that fall disproportionately on minority youths. during this provocative new e-book, Barry Feld examines what went mistaken with the juvenile court docket and proposes an alternate version for adolescence crime keep an eye on and baby welfare.

The innovative reformers who created the juvenile courtroom a century in the past observed youngsters as fairly innocent and blameless. yet fresh many years of emerging crime premiums linked to city decay have strained this tolerant view of younger offenders. Feld relates the 1967 perfect courtroom determination In re Gault to the wider social and criminal alterations linked to the civil rights circulate and the Warren Court's "Due strategy Revolution." even if gault mandated extra tricky procedural safeguards in delinquency hearings, sarcastically, these protections legitimated the imposition of extra punitive sanctions.

Since Gault, Feld argues, 3 many years of judicial, legislative, and administrative reforms have performed a sort of "criminological triage." on the "soft end," reforms have shifted noncriminal prestige offenders, essentially lady and white, out of the juvenile justice approach right into a "hidden approach" made of deepest zone psychological future health and chemical dependency amenities. on the "hard end," states move expanding numbers of younger offenders, disproportionately minorities, to legal court docket for prosecution as adults. in the meantime, juvenile courts punish extra critically these delinquents-again disproportionately minorities-who stay in the more and more criminalized juvenile justice system.

Feld attributes the present situation to a conceptual flaw inherent within the juvenile courtroom. The juvenile justice method makes an attempt to mix social welfare and social keep an eye on capabilities in a single association, yet necessarily fulfills either missions badly as a result of the inherent and irreconcilable contradictions among them. innovative reformers positioned the juvenile court docket on a few cultural, criminal, and criminological fault strains, the place the guidelines of kid and grownup, determinism and loose will, immature and liable, therapy and punishment collide. The prior 3 a long time have witnessed a shift from the previous to the latter of those binary pairs according to the racial transformation of towns, the rise in critical adolescence crime, and the erosion of the rehabilitative assumptions of the juvenile courtroom.

the answer, Feld argues, is to uncouple social welfare from felony social regulate. States may well try out all offenders in a single built-in felony justice method with acceptable changes to house the youthfulness of more youthful defendants: a graduated, age-culpability sentencing process, separate formative years correctional amenities, and so on. officially spotting youthfulness as a mitigating issue would offer youths with larger protections and justice than they at the moment obtain in both the juvenile or felony justice platforms. while the sort of process may permit public guidelines to handle without delay the social welfare wishes of all younger people.

Show description

Read Online or Download Bad Kids: Race and the Transformation of the Juvenile Court (Studies in Crime and Public Policy) PDF

Best minority studies books

Women in the Chemical Workforce: A Workshop Report to the Chemical Sciences Roundtable

For a interval of background no ladies labored outdoor the house. Bust as years have passed by and society has replaced, girls are operating various jobs each day. they're, despite the fact that, underrepresented in a few sectors of jobs. This comprises girls within the engineering and technological know-how fields. To issues worse, ladies don't ascend the profession ladder as quick as or so far as males do.

Policy Responses To Social Exclusion (UK Higher Education OUP Humanities & Social Sciences Sociology)

This article examines present coverage responses to s0cial exclusion. It starts via asking the questions: what can we suggest via social exclusion? what are the size of social exclusion? how is it measured? and what are the typical threads that run although modern coverage? each one contribution addresses a unique region of coverage, describing the context for the intervention, reading key topics and matters and assessing the most likely effectiveness of rules.

Becoming Mexican American: Ethnicity, Culture, and Identity in Chicano Los Angeles, 1900-1945

Twentieth-century l. a. has been the locus of 1 of the main profound and complicated interactions among version cultures in American historical past. but this research is likely one of the first to check the connection among ethnicity and id one of the biggest immigrant crew to that urban. by means of targeting Mexican immigrants to l. a. from 1900 to 1945, George J.

Additional resources for Bad Kids: Race and the Transformation of the Juvenile Court (Studies in Crime and Public Policy)

Example text

People perceived the young who managed to survive as small adults who did not require any special social or legal status. Lloyd deMause (1974:1) describes the early history of childhood as a "nightmare," a chronicle in which adults "killed, abandoned, beat, terrorized, and sexually abused" young people. Child-rearing practices, such as wet nursing, swaddling, physical restraint, immobilization, beating, and inattention, in the Middle Ages contributed to high rates of infant mortality (deMause 1974; Shorter 1975).

Hall and other child-study researchers asserted that childhood consisted of a series of developmental stages and sharply differentiated between children and adults. Hall's theory of recapitulation analogized child development with human evolutionary history—"ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny"—and compared childhood with primitive violent savagery and adulthood with mature developed society (Kett 1977:218). Recapitulation fit neatly with contemporaneous Darwinian evolutionary theory, and child-study proponents believed that their scientific discipline would provide insights into human culture, social development, and more effective socialization of the young.

Moreover, simply because children were being seen for the first time as special, the family's reason for being, its justification as it were, was increasingly related to the proper rearing of children" (Degler 1980:66). Analyses of nineteenth-century children's books and parents' childrearing manuals corroborate the emergence of new ideas of childhood during this period (Wishy 1968). Social historians concur that adults increasingly viewed children as vulnerable, innocent, and dependent beings whom parents needed to protect and prepare for life (Kett 1977; Platt 1977; Hawes and Miner 1985).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.79 of 5 – based on 45 votes